That's why I was initially turned off from cloth diapering. Yes, people still do cloth diapering, and it's actually becoming quite trendy. I did some research into it to figure out what it would cost and what kind of work it would involve, and I discovered what Ryan and I call The Church of the Holy Cloth Diaper. It's doctrines include such "facts" (which may or may not be true--but I didn't see a lot of citation or good proof in the things I read) as: Each baby will add about two tons of diapers to the landfills (we calculated this and it actually seems about right), disposable diapers have all sorts of toxic and harmful ingredients that are bad for the environment and your baby's skin and lungs, the dirty diapers in landfills are polluting our groundwater, it takes several hundred years for a disposable diaper to decompose (don't know how they figured that one out), and so on. Like I said, I don't know if these things are true or not. It's probably a mixture of truth and falsehoods (made up, discovered from bad science, spread and distorted by word of mouth . . . who knows?). But I didn't like the feeling that all these people are trying to make good mothers feel guilty about something as minor as what they use to cover their babies' bottoms--there are so many other things that are infinitely more important in good mothering. Then I saw the prices for some of the cloth diapers that are available, and I decided that somebody is cheating people in the name of saving the environment. One BumGenius diaper is $17.95. Yes, they're really nice cloth diapers with everything built in and they will fit the baby all throughout their diapering days, but I'm still not sure if they're worth quite that much. And you can get other diapers that are even more expensive that are supposed to be even more "environmentally friendly." Maybe I'm just cheap, but that was my impression. So that was why at first I decided not to do cloth diapering--I felt that a lot of people were getting pretty extreme, and since that made me uncomfortable, I didn't want to support it or get involved. I'm not saying that it's wrong to use cloth diapers as a way to protect the environment--I'm saying that if you get so religious about it that you forget about doctrines of the Church of Jesus Christ, then there's a problem.
By the way, washing and drying cloth diapers does take a lot of energy and water. It seems to me that it's hard to tell whether disposable diapers filling up landfills is better or worse than polluting the atmosphere and using lots of water.
That being said, we did ultimately decide to start using cloth diapers. But I am NOT a member of The Church of the Holy Cloth Diaper. We only did it to save money. We have been using cloth diapers for Kevin since mid-December. And I actually really like it. We calculated that about the time of Kevin's first birthday, the cloth diapers will have paid for themselves, and after that we will be making money. Plus, I don't have to haul sacks of dirty disposable diapers all the way to the dumpster (which is a bit of a distance from our apartment . . . yes, I'm lazy). I would much rather do a little laundry than be constantly carrying smelly sacks to the dumpster.
Speaking of "all that laundry," I don't think it's that bad. We wash diapers about every other day, so that's 3-4 times per week. I do a rinse cycle and then a regular wash cycle. It takes less than a minute to put the dirty diapers in the washing machine and start the rinse, 15 seconds to add soap and start the regular wash cycle, about a minute to transfer the diapers to the dryer and hang up the covers, and about five minutes to sort it all out and put it away after the dryer is finished. So I would guess I spend at the most half an hour per week washing diapers, and I haven't noticed the missing half hour. It's not like I have to stay there the whole time they're washing. Laundry isn't really a chore for me, though. I rather enjoy it. If I had to slap my diapers on rocks to wash them and then ring them out and hang them out on the line to dry, I would say no, it is definitely not worth it to do cloth diapering. I have no idea how the pioneer mothers did it. But with a washer and dryer to do it all for me, it's not so bad.
Yes, the soiled diapers are disgusting. It's hard to not touch dirty toilet water when you're dunking a dirty diaper. But I bought some rubber gloves for $0.82 and now it's not that bad. And the first rinse cycle in the washer gets off whatever doesn't come off easily. P.S. If you're worried about the smell, well, you have to deal with smelly diapers whether you do cloth or disposable diapers. I haven't smelled a difference.
Some people rave about how you get fewer diaper rashes with cloth. That hasn't been my experience. Maybe it's because I'm using prefolds instead of fancy BumGenius diapers (to save a couple hundred dollars). But we never saw the trace of a rash until we started using cloth. I think it's because disposable diapers are built to pull the moisture into the diaper and away from the baby's skin, and since prefolds are just cloth, they don't do that, so the moisture stays against Kevin's skin. I started using A&D (the kind with zinc oxide) before I put him to bed for the night, and that seems to keep the rashes away for the most part. As an experiment, I stopped using the A&D for a couple of days to see if a rash would appear, and he did get a rash (obviously, I would have to do more tests to make this a reliable experiment). I imagine it depends on the baby and a lot of different factors.
Oh, and in my experience, cloth diapers don't usually leak. With disposable diapers, we had to deal with at least one leak per day, and more than that when he was very small .
You really can save money by using cloth diapers, as long as you don't get too crazy with all the extras or try to collect all different kinds of diapers and if you're careful with shipping costs. There are things like wipe warmers, special cloth baby wipe solution (you can make your own for pennies), expensive "natural" detergents (you do have to be careful about which detergent you use because some cause buildup on the diapers, but there are cheap brands that work just fine), diaper doublers (again, you could probably make your own), and other things that might not really be necessary, although if they make life nicer for you then feel free to use them. You also have to factor in the cost of using the washer and dryer more often. Our energy and water are a flat rate, so the cost of those hasn't increased for us. I'd be interested to hear if it's still worthwhile from someone whose utilities depend on amount of usage. Here is a breakdown of what we have paid for diapers:
- 36 premium size prefolds (factory seconds from clothdiaper.com): $57.03
- Several flat diapers that my mom made but never used: $0 (or several hundred dollars if you count the plane trip : ) )
- 4 Thirsties size 2 Duo diaper covers (bought from a local store, so no shipping costs involved): $54.95
- 2 yards of flannel to make 25 two-layer cloth wipes: $8.07
- Squirt bottle for squirting wipe solution on wipes: $1
- Baby oil and baby wash for wipe solution: $0 (I got a lot of those at the baby shower)
- Trash can for holding dirty diapers: $8.99
- Rubber gloves: $0.82
- Old pillowcase for wetbag: $0 (I'm going to make something better when I have the time, though.)
To explain what kind of diapers we use: Prefolds are basically several layers of cotton stitched together, with more layers in the middle than on the sides. Flat diapers are a big piece of cloth that you fold into a diaper shape--this actually isn't that hard, and sometimes I prefer flats because they are less bulky than prefolds, which means K can wear some of his older pairs of pants. The Thirsties diaper covers are kind of like the plastic pants of my babyhood, except they are made of nicer plastic that's not so rustly and they are shaped like a disposable diaper with elastic around the legs and velcro to fasten them. They come in two sizes and have snaps so that you can adjust the size as the baby grows, which means you only have to buy two sets of covers--one for when they're small, and one for when they're big. I don't use any pins. I just lay the diaper in the cover and fasten it with the velcro, tucking in any loose fabric from the cloth part when I'm done. The covers can usually be used several times before needing to be washed. The prefolds will definitely last for more than one child. I'm not sure about the covers. They might wear out. They are starting to pill a little bit at the legs.
Here's what K looks like in his cloth diapers:
Pretty cute, huh? I think cloth diapers are cuter than disposable diapers. I was never much of a fan of the v-shaped, saturated disposable diaper look. Kevin does look kind of like a pear sometimes when his clothes cover the diaper, though--they are a lot more bulky than disposable diapers.
Oh, and I have nothing against BumGenius diapers. The only reason we chose prefolds and covers was because it was a slightly cheaper option. BumGenius seem to be really great diapers.
Anyway, I thought I'd share my thoughts because they're a little different than what most people who write about it seem to think. There are a lot of good reasons to use cloth diapers, and there are also plenty of valid reasons to not use cloth diapers, and I wouldn't want anyone to think I don't respect them because of the kind of diaper they use.
2 comments:
Thanks for sharing this. I'm with you on the "Holy church of the cloth diaper" thing--I've seen quite a few blog posts about it. I like your sane, researched perspective. I think that if we went that route, it would be more of a financial reason than an environmental footprint reason. This gives me something to think about as we're gearing up for large loads of diapers again!
I love that you decided to use cloth diapers for very practical reasons. The environmental reasons never seemed enough reason to make the jump to cloth diapers! I wish I had read this post 10 years ago!!!
Post a Comment