(I'm really sorry if some people are offended by this running commentary about potty training Kevin, but I want to share it because it's been really helpful to me when other friends have shared their thoughts and experiences. So if you don't want to know, don't read it, and don't think less of me.)
June 11 (Monday):
Over the last weekend we started talking and decided it might be a good idea to try potty training again. We're moving to a new apartment (that is most likely getting new carpet) in a month and a half, so that is one motivation. The other reason is that we feel like Kevin is ready and just needs to be given some time and encouragement. He knows how to use the toilet and has done so many times before, and what we are really aiming for is for him to do it consistently and to recognize the need to go every time.
I've tried a lot of different strategies in the past. I've used elements of Toilet Training in a Day, I've tried letting him run around in underwear, I've tried having him clean up and the practice running to the toilet, and I've tried a lot of other things. A lot of my attempts have just made him more resistant. One of the things I've come to realize is that for him it's important that it's his own accomplishment. I was rereading parts of the book
How to Make the Terrible Twos Terrific! a few days ago, and when the author talks about potty training he gives a very interesting insight. Potty training is not about hygiene. It's not about not having to change the kid's diapers anymore. It's about the child gaining independence. When I read that I realized that needs to be the underlying goal this time around. And that is the most frustrating thing about this entire process. I can force him into his carseat, I can pick him up and put him in his bed, I can physically drag him kicking and screaming from the playground, but I can't force him to recognize that he needs to go to the bathroom and go use the toilet. I can't force motivation.
So this time I am trying to look at myself as the consultant and the guide while Kevin figures it out for himself. And I fully expect it to take several weeks.
Day 1 (Monday, June 11):
We had several accidents and one success. I was changing Heidi's diaper before naps and she was dry, so I put her on the froggy potty just to see if she would go. She actually did go, and then Kevin wanted to help dump it in the toilet, so I let him. And then he independently decided to wet in the toilet (the regular one--he isn't interested in using the froggy potty). That was exciting. Since he had gone just before his naps, I let him just stay in underwear for his nap. I was sort of expecting to have to change wet sheets, but when I went in to get him I found that he had just climbed out of his bed and then wet his pants. That was an indication to me that he was aware enough to get out of bed before releasing. Interesting.
Day 2:
Several accidents and one success, again. I had a headache all day and didn't get to lie down much, so it was a rough day. I was not a very nice mom.
Day 3:
A couple of accidents in the morning. I decided to put a diaper on him during his nap, and when he got up from his nap I found that his diaper was completely soaked and had leaked a lot on his clothes. I'm getting concerned that he'll just hold it all the time and then release in his sleep. Then I remembered another idea I read in the terrible twos book and had a feeling I should try it. So I set a timer for one hour. When it beeped, I said, "That's the potty bell! It's time to try going potty." He was very resistant (as he always is when we suggest that he try), and then on the way to the bathroom it occurred to me to tell him he could have a cookie if he would try. It worked. Once I set him on the toilet and handed him the cookie he was okay with it and stayed there for a while. He didn't go, so I set the timer for another hour and told him we'd try again later. The next time I used the same strategy, and this time he wet in the toilet, so we gave him another cookie. A little while later he independently decided to go again and had another success. I didn't want to resort to using treats, especially because generally bribery doesn't work so well with him, but at the same time I feel like he needs a little guidance so that he can go to the potty regularly, and this is a way that we can help him learn to try without having to force him into it. We might have to go from cookies to a few chocolate chips, though, because six to eight cookies a day doesn't seem like a very good idea.
Day 4:
Well, the potty timer idea didn't work for long. I just don't know what to do. I feel like I'm just causing problems if I even suggest that Kevin try using the toilet, but I'm afraid to just not say anything because then he'll just go on the floor. I really feel like we just need to get this over with because Kevin is ready in all the other ways and I doubt he will ever be motivated enough to potty train himself without some help. But forcing the issue is just going to cause problems. He knows what to do, but he won't do it. I have no idea why he is so resistant. I don't think he's afraid of the toilet. Maybe it's fear of the unknown (i.e. not wearing diapers anymore) or not wanting to be controlled.
Day 5:
Kevin was disturbingly bored and I made a last minute decision to take him to a children's museum, Kidzu. That meant I had to make the decision about going in public with or without a diaper. I opted for underwear (Kevin asked for it) with a diaper over it and felt good about that. We had a fun time and rode the bus there and back. When we got home, Kevin was still dry, so I asked if he would try to go potty. He said he would if he could have some marshmallows, so I said that would be fine. And he went! He also went again later in the evening after some pressure from Ryan. I find myself clinging to these successes as hope that things will get better. I still feel like this is going to be a long, hard road, but I guess I shouldn't be too surprised.
After a week and a half:
Something clicked or something and the last few days have gone a lot better. Most of the time Kevin will go wet in the toilet if we suggest it or take him, which is a complete change from what the first few days were like. He doesn't take the initiative and go by himself, but if we take him he will go if he needs to. So every couple of hours we will suggest it and he will go. I don't call that potty-trained, but I definitely consider it a step in the right direction. Sometimes he asks for marshmallows as a reward, and I don't mind giving them if he asks. I don't get the feeling that he is going to need that incentive for long. I feel more optimistic now. The new question is how in the world to get him to go #2 in the toilet, but I'm grateful for some success.
The next day:
We had some good successes today. While we were out playing in the lobby with some friends, Kevin decided (unprompted) to use the public restroom there . . . three times. So maybe I don't need to worry so hard about the public/foreign restroom thing. The other thing is that this evening Kevin went #2 in the froggy potty. That was a big leap for him (hmmm . . . not sure how I feel about that pun). He was sort of uncertain and had a hard time. But hopefully he's learned a lot and will keep moving forward in that department. I'm proud of Kevin for all that he is learning. He's really growing up.
6/28
Kevin is continuing to make slow progress. On Sunday we took the risk and took him to church in underwear. He refused to use any of the toilets at the church every time we tried to take him, then just before we left he suddenly expressed an interest in using the small toilet that is in the bathroom in the back of the nursery room. Problem was, it was clogged and also leaking water. But he went willingly once we got home. Occasionally he lets us know he wants to try, but most of the time I just have to remind him every few hours. He's gotten a lot more agreeable about it. Still not sure what we're going to do about #2, though. But I'm grateful that this is working, even if it's slow!