We've been listening to the soundtrack from Mulan in the car lately, and I've been struck by the differences in the men and women's perspectives about relationships and the opposite gender in the movie as demonstrated in the songs Honor to Us All and A Girl Worth Fighting For. I thought I'd do a compare and contrast to show the differences. Keep in mind that I don't necessarily think these are a good representation of what men and women think (either in Western culture or Chinese culture), but there are some good/true points here.
What the women think the men want:
"Men want girls with good taste
Calm
Obedient
Who work fast-paced
With good breeding
And a tiny waist."
What the men really want:
"I want her paler than the
moon with eyes that
shine like stars."
"My girl will marvel at
my strength, adore my
battle scars."
"I couldn't care less what she'll
wear or what she looks like.
It all depends on what
she cooks like."
"My girl will think I have no faults,
That I'm a major find."
So the women think that the men want girls to be good housewives and have a nice figure. Some of the men do want nice-looking girls, but it seems like the main thing they want is someone who admires them and takes care of them and is willing to overlook their faults (which can be a good thing, depending on how the wife goes about it).
What the men think the women want:
"My girl will marvel at
my strength, adore my
battle scars."
"And I'll bet the ladies love
a man in armor."
"My manly ways and turn of
phrase are sure to thrill her."
"But when we come home
in victory they'll line up
at the door."
What the women actually want:
"Boys will gladly go to war for you."
"Please look kindly on
these cultured pearls,
Each a perfect porcelain doll."
"Ancestors,
Hear my plea:
Help me not to make a
fool of me
And to not uproot
my family tree.
Keep my father standing tall."
So the men think that women want them to be manly and that they admire soldiers. That is mentioned in Honor to Us All, but the women are by far more preoccupied with bringing honor to their families (based on what I read in the book Wild Swans this is fairly representative of Chinese culture before World War II and the rise of the Communist Party there) and being the model of a perfect woman, which isn't actually that related to what the men think of them. It's more about what their society, especially the other women, think of them. I think this is interesting because I've noticed that women are often a lot more preoccupied with how other women perceive them than they are about how men perceive them. We dress to impress other women to show that we are put together and look nice, and we try to give the impression that we are great at taking care of our homes and such. And we do it while partly thinking that we're doing it to impress our husbands when really what the men want more than a picture-perfect housewife is someone to support and love them despite their imperfections.
(I realize that this isn't necessarily true for all men and women, but it's pretty common, and besides, this is just a fun little exercise, so don't take me too seriously.)
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
Followers
Labels
Adam and Eve
(2)
Allison
(1)
Ann Marie
(34)
anniversary
(2)
Apartment
(3)
baby
(26)
beach
(1)
beans
(6)
birth story
(3)
birthday
(14)
books
(26)
bread
(8)
breastfeeding
(3)
busy bags
(1)
camping
(1)
Christ
(19)
Christmas
(22)
Chronicles of Narnia
(1)
cleaning
(5)
cloth diapers
(4)
cooking
(15)
Couch
(1)
crafts
(2)
craigslist
(1)
croutons
(1)
Dad
(3)
date
(2)
decluttering
(10)
decorating
(3)
dreams
(1)
Easter
(1)
family
(17)
flowers
(1)
food storage
(22)
for posterity
(4)
friends
(2)
gate
(1)
genealogy
(6)
goals
(5)
gratitude
(1)
hair
(6)
Halloween
(5)
health
(13)
Heidi
(117)
Holy Ghost
(8)
ice cream
(6)
joy
(1)
July 2014 trip
(12)
K
(222)
laundry
(6)
Learning in the Gospel
(5)
miracles
(3)
miscarriage
(1)
motherhood
(53)
music
(7)
names
(2)
nutrimill
(2)
oatmeal
(2)
occupational therapy
(4)
old wives' tales
(1)
peace
(3)
pie
(5)
potty training
(2)
powdered milk
(2)
pregnancy
(6)
projects
(16)
questions
(3)
rants
(13)
repentance
(8)
Rolling Over
(2)
RT
(24)
Ruby
(1)
school
(61)
service
(5)
sewing
(12)
shopping
(8)
snow
(7)
SPD
(3)
temperance
(1)
temple
(5)
Thanksgiving
(9)
things we have done
(119)
thoughts
(160)
trials
(9)
tummy
(9)
Utah trip 2012
(7)
van
(2)
voting
(2)
weather
(6)
weddings
(2)
wheat
(5)
No comments:
Post a Comment