Sunday, May 1, 2011

Data, please.

I think that one effect that studying geology has had on me is that data is more important to me. It's one thing to draw a picture and color it in and say, "See? This is how hotspots work." But just because you draw a picture or even make an animation doesn't make it so. It's important to have the data to back up an idea. That involves studying the chemistry and mineralogy of the rocks, observing formations and making geologic maps, examining how seismic waves move in an area, and many other things. Then you organize the data in a way that makes it possible to analyze it, and you see if the data matches your ideas, or if it suggests other ideas.

I've found that this attitude is starting to spill over into other things I see or read about from day to day. For example, I have a bottle of St. Ives lotion in my bathroom, and the other day I was noticing an explanation of some of the ingredients printed on the back. Here's what it says:

Olive Leaf Extract: Known to restore dry skin with its skin-nourishing moisturization.
Cranberry Seed Oil: This nutrient rich antioxidant is known to relieve dry, itchy skin.
Grape Seed Oil: Known to prevent future skin damage.

So I read that and the first thing that went through my head was, "Where's your citation? Where's the study that proves that those things are known to actually do that?" Now, I'm not complaining about the lotion. I've found recently that I'm allergic to many lotions, and St. Ives is one that I know doesn't make red bumps break out all over my skin and I also know that it is effective at keeping my hands and wrists nice and smooth. But it occurred to me that you can write anything you want on the back of a bottle of lotion, but that doesn't make it so. I want to see the study that made it so we "know" those ingredients do those things.

It seems like you can make just about any claim, and if you can get enough people to believe it and spread the idea, then it will become "common knowledge" and people will start saying that it is known that the claim is true when in fact it was just made up or was purely anecdote. It helps if people already want the claim to be true, because then you just have to present it as fact and people say it's just what they always thought and they had been waiting for a study that would prove it. The internet has made it easy to find that kind of thing, and it's getting harder to sift through it to find the good information.

No comments:

Blog Archive

Followers