In the class about teaching that I took at North Carolina State University a couple of years ago, one of the things they kept telling us we needed to do was to try to have the students figure out the concepts on their own, rather than just handing them the definition or telling them how things work right away. To demonstrate what they meant, they would give us activities to do without giving us enough background information. We spent the entire hour and a half doing the activity before we figured out what was going on, and it was incredibly frustrating, and in the end I only felt like I had picked up a couple of small concepts. Or they would tell us that instead of directly giving the answer to a student's question, we should ask them questions to guide them to the answer or have them keep trying or only give small hints. I never felt that it was effective when they used this method, nor had it been effective when I had tried to use it as a TA for Physical Science 100 at BYU.
Now, I don't want to completely discount what they were trying to encourage us to do. I do believe that there is value in giving students opportunities to discover concepts on their own. I think what was frustrating was that I believed they had a point, but I had never really seen anyone effectively use this principle.
This semester, I think I finally saw it happen, though. My mineralogy teacher uses this method effectively, and it doesn't even take 10 times as long as just giving a lecture. For most of our classes, he gave us In Class Exercises (ICEs), which we worked through with a partner while he and the TA walked around answering questions. The ICEs were generally about 6-8 pages long (it took a couple of weeks to get through one ICE), and they guided us through the process of figuring out the concepts he wanted us to learn. He gave us background information throughout the exercise, and he also asked very effective guiding questions that helped us apply the things we already knew. We often figured out the new concepts ourselves as we answered the questions on the ICE. Every so often he had "STOP!!" printed on the page, and when we got to that point we stopped working until everyone had caught up (we generally didn't have to wait very long). Then we discussed it all as a class to make sure everyone got it right or to get help where we all got stuck. So instead of handing out a lab with no background information and telling us to figure it out in an hour, he had a lesson plan that built up the concepts as we went along, so that we were still learning at a reasonable pace and not getting bored or too frustrated, and we were discovering things for ourselves. I found that classtime usually whizzed by and I felt actively engaged in learning the concepts.
I've been really excited to learn about this way of teaching. It's shown me that it really is possible to facilitate students figuring out new concepts themselves rather than just telling them everything. I guess in my heart I still see myself teaching science if I end up needing to get a job, because I find myself conjuring lesson plans in my head and thinking of ways to use ICEs to teach my students. Then again, I'm not so sure I want to go back to high school, not even as a teacher.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2010
(140)
-
▼
December
(14)
- to yell or not
- throwing away the dresser
- ICEs
- our little hamster
- 32
- happy news
- sweet potato fries
- books and school and Christmas prep
- how to prepare for college
- Knowledge, a Gift of the Spirit
- oops
- Well, this afternoon was my Calculus final. Unless...
- Telling the stories of Jesus
- a little guessing game
-
▼
December
(14)
Followers
Labels
Adam and Eve
(2)
Allison
(1)
Ann Marie
(34)
anniversary
(2)
Apartment
(3)
baby
(26)
beach
(1)
beans
(6)
birth story
(3)
birthday
(14)
books
(26)
bread
(8)
breastfeeding
(3)
busy bags
(1)
camping
(1)
Christ
(19)
Christmas
(22)
Chronicles of Narnia
(1)
cleaning
(5)
cloth diapers
(4)
cooking
(15)
Couch
(1)
crafts
(2)
craigslist
(1)
croutons
(1)
Dad
(3)
date
(2)
decluttering
(10)
decorating
(3)
dreams
(1)
Easter
(1)
family
(17)
flowers
(1)
food storage
(22)
for posterity
(4)
friends
(2)
gate
(1)
genealogy
(6)
goals
(5)
gratitude
(1)
hair
(6)
Halloween
(5)
health
(13)
Heidi
(117)
Holy Ghost
(8)
ice cream
(6)
joy
(1)
July 2014 trip
(12)
K
(222)
laundry
(6)
Learning in the Gospel
(5)
miracles
(3)
miscarriage
(1)
motherhood
(53)
music
(7)
names
(2)
nutrimill
(2)
oatmeal
(2)
occupational therapy
(4)
old wives' tales
(1)
peace
(3)
pie
(5)
potty training
(2)
powdered milk
(2)
pregnancy
(6)
projects
(16)
questions
(3)
rants
(13)
repentance
(8)
Rolling Over
(2)
RT
(24)
Ruby
(1)
school
(61)
service
(5)
sewing
(12)
shopping
(8)
snow
(7)
SPD
(3)
temperance
(1)
temple
(5)
Thanksgiving
(9)
things we have done
(119)
thoughts
(160)
trials
(9)
tummy
(9)
Utah trip 2012
(7)
van
(2)
voting
(2)
weather
(6)
weddings
(2)
wheat
(5)
No comments:
Post a Comment