Saturday, September 15, 2012

some thoughts on God and philosophy

In my Philosophy of Religion class we have been discussing several issues with the nature of God. In the past week and a half we have spent a lot of time discussing whether God can be omnipotent and omniscient.

There is a pretty well-known paradox that challenges the idea that God is omnipotent (i.e. can do anything). If God can do anything, can He create a stone that is too heavy for him to lift? The difficulty is that if he can create the stone, that means He can't lift it, which means He is not omnipotent because there is something He cannot do. On the other hand, if He can't create it, then there is still something He cannot do, so He is not omnipotent. The author of the paper we read about this had an interesting solution to this problem. He said that before creating the stone, God is still omnipotent, because He could create the stone, even if He chose not to. After He creates the stone, He is no longer omnipotent. So in order to remain omnipotent, God chooses not to create the stone.

With respect to omniscience, one of the difficulties is that if God is omniscient it seems like we can't have free will, because if God knows everything, then He knows everything we will do, which means that everything we will do is already decided. The same author had an interesting solution to that problem too. He pointed out that if God knows everything that we will do, He also knows everything that He himself will do, which limits His own free will. So the author concludes that while God could know everything about the future, He chooses to limit His knowledge in order to preserve His own free will and our free will.

These topics were not completely new to me because Ryan did a second major in philosophy at BYU, so we've talked about these things before. But one of the things that struck me as I was reading the papers was that these problems with the nature of God don't really bother me. I've been aware of them, but I'm not worried that God can't make a stone too heavy for Him to lift or that He can or can't see the future. The reason it doesn't bother me is because these problems focus on God's power. They're worrisome because they seem to diminish God's power. And what I am realizing is that I'm not bothered by that because to me, the reason God is God is not because of His power. God is God because He is good.

No comments:

Blog Archive

Followers