Saturday, June 16, 2012

Goodreads Review: David O. McKay and the Rise of Modern Mormonism


David O. McKay and the Rise of Modern MormonismDavid O. McKay and the Rise of Modern Mormonism by Gregory A. Prince
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

I thought this book was really interesting and gave some good insights into the changes the LDS church was going through while David O. McKay was the prophet. If you read it you need to recognize that prophets are human and that they make mistakes, which is why I feel a little hesitant to recommend it to just anybody. The authors were trying to make this an objective book and present the facts, not rave about how wonderful David O. McKay was. I think when you read this book you have to recognize that the church is not stagnant and it has to change to accommodate growth and current events, and you also have to recognize that we are still figuring out how God wants the church to be led. We had to figure out how we would deal with politics, building, finances, organization, etc., and at the time of President McKay our position in some of those areas wasn't established yet, which led to some misunderstandings and conflicts. But in the end I was left feeling very impressed with him and what was accomplished while he was the prophet.

I was impressed at the insights he had in implementing the building program. It was very important to him because he recognized that it was difficult for the church to grow when outside of the United States the members didn't have decent places to meet, which meant they didn't leave a very good impression. (Try inviting your friends to come to Sacrament Meeting in the back room of a bar.) The church grew much more rapidly after nice meetinghouses and temples started being built throughout the world. One of the effects of this was that instead of telling members to come to Zion, they were encouraged to stay where they were and build Zion there, which meant that people with good testimonies stayed put and built up the church throughout the world, so that the church became an international church instead of just a Utah church.

There is a very interesting chapter about the issue of black people receiving the priesthood. It discusses many of the misconceptions around that issue--i.e. they were less faithful/fence-sitters in the war in Heaven, they are cursed because they are descendants of Cain/Ham, etc. (none of which are true). Like I said before, you have to realize that prophets are human and are not perfect. A lot of the apostles at the time had grown up with some views that were racist and because of that they didn't think that black people should have the priesthood. It was interesting to note that Spencer W. Kimball was silent on this issue--and years later he was the prophet who was able to announce that all men would receive the priesthood. People didn't seem to have a very good impression of the civil rights movement here in the West, which is partly understandable since there weren't a lot of black people there. Some of the apostles at the time seem to have associated that civil rights movement with the spread of Communism (especially Ezra Taft Benson). Anyway, I learned a lot of interesting things about the perspective the leaders of the church had at the time on civil rights and black people receiving the priesthood. I get the impression that as time went President McKay learned a lot about the issue and by the time he died was hoping that soon the blacks would be able to receive the priesthood.

Free agency (the ability to choose right and wrong) was really important to President McKay, and because of that I thought he had some really good insights into why Communism is a bad idea. He felt that taking away free agency was a crime and prevents people from making spiritual progress, and from all the things I have studied about Communism, that is exactly what tends to happen under Communist rule.


View all my reviews

No comments:

Blog Archive

Followers