Going through some of my drafts, I came across this post I started in January. I think I was planning to add more to it, but I don't really remember anymore what I was going to add, so here's what you get.
I've been hearing a lot about the book Nurture Shock lately, so I wanted to read it myself. And in the end, I honestly didn't like it for the most part. Most of the "shocking truths" that he was "revealing" were not that shocking. What? You mean kids learn how to talk better if you talk to them rather than plopping them down in front of Baby Einstein videos? Not that surprising. I think the most frustrating thing was that he dispelled all these myths but didn't usually spend much time at all explaining what to do instead. When he did suggest what to do instead, it was helpful.
Here are some of the thoughts I have been having as I read the book:
The chapter about dealing with teenagers was not helpful. His claim was that when teenagers argue with their parents, it's actually a good sign because it shows they respect their parents. I don't know what his definition of respect is, but I strongly disagree. There was very little helpful information about getting along with teenagers better.
There's a chapter in the book about why siblings fight. I thought it was important to note that kids need to be taught how to play well together. Much of that should be figured out with each other, but they also need parents to intervene to help them think through how to solve a conflict together. Another thing that stuck out to me was that if you want your kids to be friends and get along with each other, then they need to spend quality time together. That quality time is something that cements a bond between them and creates a reason for them to be kind to each other. One study that the author summarizes said that for the most part, if siblings were good friends growing up, then they continue to be friends as adults, but if they are not close growing up, then that doesn't change when they have grown up.
From the same chapter, I also thought that it was interesting that in one of the studies the author explained, difference in age had no effect on how much siblings quarreled. I think sometimes in the church we tend to feel like the ideal age gap is supposed to be two years, and I've noticed that some moms struggle because of that expectation. Sometimes I've felt like if your kids are less than two years apart, people look at your family and say, "Hmmm . . . second baby must have been a surprise!" And if your kids are more than two years apart, I felt like people would wonder why you waited so long--not spiritual enough? I quickly came to the conclusion that it doesn't matter. It's a very personal and spiritual decision. I also started to realize that most moms actually don't care or judge each other on this subject, even though that two years apart thing is so commonly expected. We all know that it's hard to be a mother. Long recoveries, post-partum depression, difficult children, other commitments, and many other factors are perfectly legitimate reasons to not be ready for a second child that soon. So it was nice for me to read in this book that age difference doesn't necessarily matter if you want your kids to be close and get along. What's important is that we space our children according to what we feel is right, and that we teach them to love each other and be kind. (Stepping down from soapbox.)
The chapter about tests for finding gifted children was very interesting to me. Apparently most schools test children for gifted and talented programs at kindergarten and then never reassess them. But the tests at that age are actually not good predictors of whether children are gifted. A lot of brain development takes place during elementary school, and the kids that struggle in kindergarten often end up being very bright. I didn't realize that this happens so often. My elementary school didn't do its gifted and talented programs this way. (After moving away from my small hometown, I've actually realized that I went to a very good elementary school.) It really isn't fair to a child to label them as smart or not smart at such a young age when they still have so much time for their brains to develop.
I thought that the chapter about the inverse power of praise made some very good points. One of the main things I learned was that it's important to praise our children for things that they can control about themselves. Instead of telling them that they are smart, it's better to praise them for being diligent or patient or for trying hard to concentrate, because those characteristics are up to the child. The author explained that many children who are constantly told they are smart tend to be more prone to give up easily. If they are not "smart" at something, then they don't want to stick with it, possibly because they don't want to not be seen as smart.
He had a chapter about how to help children learn how to talk. He talked about how seven hours of Baby Einstein per day is not going to help a child learn to talk, and will probably actually delay their speech, which was not surprising to me at all. Another thing he talked about is that instead of talking to the child constantly all day long, it can be more effective to simply pay attention to them and respond to the cues they give you. This made a lot of sense to me. I've heard from a lot of different places that you want to talk to your children constantly so they will learn lots of words, but that was discouraging for me because I just can't interact with my child like that. It seems fake and it's exhausting to talk that much. It makes a lot more sense to me to talk in response to what the child does. If Kevin is doing something or pointing at something, then I respond to that by talking about what he's doing or telling him the name of what he is pointing at (and I try to get down and play with him when I can so that we will have opportunities for this), or if we're outside I will point to different things and talk to him about them, but I don't just babble all day long about anything and everything. It seems like this way the child doesn't get overwhelmed by a constant stream of talking, they learn the concept of conversation (both listening and responding), and they learn to use the words that are most relevant to them. (Oh, dear, I don't feel like I explained this very well.)
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2011
(144)
-
▼
March
(18)
- learning to talk
- not my day . . . but it got better
- Helping Dad
- 6 (ish) months pregnant
- Singing The Itsy Bitsy Spider
- AZ trip part 6: last day
- AZ trip part 5: Desert Botanical Gardens
- AZ trip part 4: Sunday and Birthday Dinner
- AZ trip part 3: Hieroglyphic Trail
- AZ trip part 2
- Me: "Kevin, can you smile for the camera?" Kevin:...
- random musings
- notes/thoughts from Nurture Shock
- scared of the phone
- Have You Forgotten?
- AZ trip part 1: the plane trip . . . or, a lesson ...
- template for a bad craigslist ad
- Sunday thoughts on motherhood
-
▼
March
(18)
Followers
Labels
Adam and Eve
(2)
Allison
(1)
Ann Marie
(34)
anniversary
(2)
Apartment
(3)
baby
(26)
beach
(1)
beans
(6)
birth story
(3)
birthday
(14)
books
(26)
bread
(8)
breastfeeding
(3)
busy bags
(1)
camping
(1)
Christ
(19)
Christmas
(22)
Chronicles of Narnia
(1)
cleaning
(5)
cloth diapers
(4)
cooking
(15)
Couch
(1)
crafts
(2)
craigslist
(1)
croutons
(1)
Dad
(3)
date
(2)
decluttering
(10)
decorating
(3)
dreams
(1)
Easter
(1)
family
(17)
flowers
(1)
food storage
(22)
for posterity
(4)
friends
(2)
gate
(1)
genealogy
(6)
goals
(5)
gratitude
(1)
hair
(6)
Halloween
(5)
health
(13)
Heidi
(117)
Holy Ghost
(8)
ice cream
(6)
joy
(1)
July 2014 trip
(12)
K
(222)
laundry
(6)
Learning in the Gospel
(5)
miracles
(3)
miscarriage
(1)
motherhood
(53)
music
(7)
names
(2)
nutrimill
(2)
oatmeal
(2)
occupational therapy
(4)
old wives' tales
(1)
peace
(3)
pie
(5)
potty training
(2)
powdered milk
(2)
pregnancy
(6)
projects
(16)
questions
(3)
rants
(13)
repentance
(8)
Rolling Over
(2)
RT
(24)
Ruby
(1)
school
(61)
service
(5)
sewing
(12)
shopping
(8)
snow
(7)
SPD
(3)
temperance
(1)
temple
(5)
Thanksgiving
(9)
things we have done
(119)
thoughts
(160)
trials
(9)
tummy
(9)
Utah trip 2012
(7)
van
(2)
voting
(2)
weather
(6)
weddings
(2)
wheat
(5)
No comments:
Post a Comment