I'm not writing this to express an opinion. Mainly I'm writing it to get out some thoughts that have been in my head.
For my history class, we are reading
India Express by Daniel Lak. One of the chapters explains how India used business process outsourcing to boost its economy. Thousands of Indians work for call centers that are located in India but that belong to American companies. They started off with IT, and they have also moved into things like customer service and tutoring. A lot of companies realized that they could outsource their customer service to India and save a lot of money because Indians are willing to do the same job for one third of the wages.
I was aware of this before, but since reading this book and getting more of the story it's been on my mind for a couple of days. A lot of people say that India is stealing American jobs, or other similar thoughts. I tend to disagree with that statement. I don't think it is stealing. But at the same time it seems wrong. I've heard many stories of competent American workers who lost their job because the company decided to outsource their job to someone in India in order to save a bundle of money. It bothers me.
The book says that Indians at the call centers do just as good a job as the American workers, or even better. To be honest, that hasn't been my experience, although my experience isn't that extensive. For example, several years ago I was having problems with my laptop, which was less than a year old. So I called HP, and ended up talking to various people, all with Indian accents, some with Indian accents so thick I could barely understand them. In the end the person who was helping me "fix" my computer didn't know what he was doing and almost got me to go through the process of wiping my hard drive and setting the computer back to how it was when I got it--without telling me this was what he was going to do. Fortunately, I realized in time what was happening, and, also fortunately, my computer randomly started working again without having to wipe my hard drive. He also suckered me into paying to extend my warranty for another year, in case something like this happened again. Let's just say, it didn't leave me with a very good impression. I have nothing against Indians, it's just that it was really irritating to call customer service and not get quality help.
I believe in capitalism. I think that in general a free and competitive market is what is needed to keep prices low and quality high. But now that economies are connected throughout the globe this is becoming a problem. Another example is Walmart. Sometimes when a Walmart is built in a city, a lot of businesses close down because they can't compete with Walmart's low prices. Again, I don't know what to think. It's not like Walmart came and bashed their windows in or stole money from them. They just started up a store.
In know there are a lot of local stores that have good-quality, unique products. I feel like I would love to support them. I admire them for working so hard to start something from scratch and make something that is a good product. I do like to buy food from the farmer's market in Raleigh, and I also buy some things from the baby boutique at the birth center here, like our diaper covers (which are completely manufactured in the United States, and also a good price). But the fact of the matter is, local is more expensive than Walmart. I can buy a shirt for Heidi at Walmart for $4, or I can buy a shirt at a local store for $15 or even more. On the one hand, I like the idea of supporting local businesses, but I am still attracted to the low prices of the Made in China stuff. I want American companies to hire Americans, but I can also understand that it's cheaper to hire thousands of people in India to do the same thing, and while it bugs me, I can't say I blame them.
So what do we do? Regulate? Just let it happen? I don't know. But if small local businesses are to survive, a new balance is going to have to be achieved.