This is pretty much a rant in response to articles like this one claiming that we are permanently debilitating our children's emotional, mental, and physical well-being by not letting them take risks and prohibiting them wandering the streets unsupervised all day. This is probably the most extreme of the posts I have seen on this issue, but the subject has been coming up a lot lately and while I agree that many parents are too overprotective and micromanage their kids' lives too much, I completely disagree that the solution is to swing to the other extreme.
One of the claims they often make is that our mothers turned us loose and let us roam the streets and woods unsupervised all day, and since nothing bad happened to us it was fine. Guess what, that story did not turn out so nicely for the ones who DID have something bad happen to them. The kids who drowned or got hit by a car or got seriously burned aren't around to tell how they wish their mom had known what they were doing. Don't underestimate the stupid things kids can do if left unchecked. Last night I was telling Ryan about some of the stupid things I did with friends while we were left unsupervised, and he looked completely unimpressed and proceeded to tell me about all the things he and his friends had done with matches, lighter fluid, and gasoline. Have you ever read Lord of the Flies? One of the things that's so disturbing about that book is that it actually sounds plausible that kids could get that crazy if left completely on their own. As parents it's our job to be there to give our children reasonable limits while they learn what behavior is acceptable and what behavior isn't. I learned my most valuable lessons at home with my family, not when I was wandering around Kimberly with my friends. There's nothing wrong with giving children reasonable limits while they develop discipline and responsibility.
Another claim is that letting kids play by themselves actually teaches them to not be bullies because they realize that nobody wants to play with them if they're mean. As someone who has been bullied by mean kids when no adults were around, I can tell you for certain that this is not true. Mean kids who enjoy making somebody cry will seek out opportunities to bully other kids no matter how hard their victims try to avoid them. Personally, I would like to know if my kids are being bullied or if they are being a bully so that I can address the issue, and I will probably only know that if I spend at least some of the time with my kids when they are playing with friends. Sure, it's good to give kids some space playing by themselves. There are some kinds of magic that don't really happen if your parents are hovering over you while you are pretending something. But sometimes you have to protect your kids from their "friends," and you will only know if that's needed if you've seen them playing together.
Family time is important. My most cherished memories are of spending time with my parents. I haven't remained close to any of my childhood friends, but I am still close to my own family. I suspect that for most kids, they would benefit a lot more from spending a little more time with their mom than from gaining a little independence by roaming the streets unsupervised.
Overall, I think we're all over-thinking it. A few days ago I went to the park with the kids. While I was sitting on the bench watching them play, I felt torn. On the one hand, I felt pleased that my kids were playing independently, but on the other hand I felt guilty that I wasn't up there chasing them around and giggling hysterically right along with them. Finally it occurred to me that it was completely absurd to analyze it so much when I should have simply enjoyed the fact that we were having a lovely time at the playground on a day with perfect weather. The truth is that if you are trying your best to instill the right values into your children, spend quality time with them, and regularly pray, read the scriptures, and have Family Home Evening together, your kids will probably turn out okay. Giving our kids enough risk or enough supervision is not the most important concern that we should have as parents.
Tuesday, April 8, 2014
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
Followers
Labels
Adam and Eve
(2)
Allison
(1)
Ann Marie
(34)
anniversary
(2)
Apartment
(3)
baby
(26)
beach
(1)
beans
(6)
birth story
(3)
birthday
(14)
books
(26)
bread
(8)
breastfeeding
(3)
busy bags
(1)
camping
(1)
Christ
(19)
Christmas
(22)
Chronicles of Narnia
(1)
cleaning
(5)
cloth diapers
(4)
cooking
(15)
Couch
(1)
crafts
(2)
craigslist
(1)
croutons
(1)
Dad
(3)
date
(2)
decluttering
(10)
decorating
(3)
dreams
(1)
Easter
(1)
family
(17)
flowers
(1)
food storage
(22)
for posterity
(4)
friends
(2)
gate
(1)
genealogy
(6)
goals
(5)
gratitude
(1)
hair
(6)
Halloween
(5)
health
(13)
Heidi
(117)
Holy Ghost
(8)
ice cream
(6)
joy
(1)
July 2014 trip
(12)
K
(222)
laundry
(6)
Learning in the Gospel
(5)
miracles
(3)
miscarriage
(1)
motherhood
(53)
music
(7)
names
(2)
nutrimill
(2)
oatmeal
(2)
occupational therapy
(4)
old wives' tales
(1)
peace
(3)
pie
(5)
potty training
(2)
powdered milk
(2)
pregnancy
(6)
projects
(16)
questions
(3)
rants
(13)
repentance
(8)
Rolling Over
(2)
RT
(24)
Ruby
(1)
school
(61)
service
(5)
sewing
(12)
shopping
(8)
snow
(7)
SPD
(3)
temperance
(1)
temple
(5)
Thanksgiving
(9)
things we have done
(119)
thoughts
(160)
trials
(9)
tummy
(9)
Utah trip 2012
(7)
van
(2)
voting
(2)
weather
(6)
weddings
(2)
wheat
(5)
No comments:
Post a Comment